The Proof Is Not Always In the Pudding….


I had a great conversation this week with some sharp and articulate moms. It was not the first time I’d had this particular conversation, and not the first time I’d seen other parents raise their eyebrows and look doubtful, as I told them that anti-semitism was alive and well, right here in our practically perfect little town. It is practically perfect, as I’ve noted in numerous posts (here, here, and here, from the archives). However, you will never hear me interviewed on the news saying: “things like that (Insert various heinous things) don’t happen here…” Never. Things happen, everywhere. Even here.

Image: tech.sc

Image: tech.sc

So as we we discussed the recent arrest of two students,  14 and 15 year old, on charges of vandalism and some other charge that equaled “hate crime,” at one of the newest and shiniest elementary schools in town (a school that one of the alleged vandals attended), and the desecration of the new synagogue, which is still under construction, conversation landed on the fact that these kids carved or painted swastikas at the school and all over the synagogue. The other mothers were shocked, and someone stated that these kids “must have gotten that at home.” Another adult I was talking to, earlier in the week, had gone so far as to say “their parents should be prosecuted as well!” Um, frankly, I don’t think so. While it is possible that these kids live in homes where they are exposed to prejudice and hate, I don’t assume that to be true. I’ve learned over many years of parenting Jewish children, that anti-semitism, racism, big bold hate rhetoric, is alive and well… with kids who we all see as “very nice.” These things don’t just come from kids who are in any particular kind of home, or come from any specific background.  And more importantly, I’ve learned that often their parents have no idea that their kids talk or act this way.

I have no idea who these particular kids are, who committed these acts. I don’t know their families, and don’t presume to know what kind of homes they come from. It’s sad that they are so young, and acting out in such destructive and mean ways, but beyond that, I know very little about where that comes from. My three children have all had swastikas drawn on their binders, and even carved on their desk (once). They have all been called: “stupid Jew, funny Jew, cheap Jew, dirty Jew, best Jew I know,” or numerous accolades followed by “for a Jew.” I can’t say honestly, that it doesn’t still burn me on the deepest levels, as a mother. However, my kids have assured me that “this is just the way it is.” They have repeatedly urged me not to get involved or “make a big deal,” as it will only cause more issues for them. “He/she was only kidding,” I’ve heard way too many times. Ha. Ha. I fail to see the humor.

On three occasions when I did get involved, when parents were called and conversations were had, I found distraught parents, who were as shocked as me that their child would launch such foul language at anyone. One father, stood at my door (with his son and wife) and became tearful, explaining that he had grown up being persecuted, and was mortified that his child would ever call my son a “stupid Jew.” That boy, was a really good kid; he still is. They are still friends. His parents are true blue, good to the bone. I believed that father when he told me this, because I have come to understand that our kids are exposed to so many things that we are often unaware of. That they say things when they often have no idea about what the words they use mean.

I’m not excusing it. Not in any way. Hate is hate, and if you don’t know what you’re kids are saying or carving, you’d better wake up and figure it out. The boys who damaged the elementary school may have thought they were being funny:  tough guys, who weren’t really doing anything “that bad,” but they committed an act of violence upon every young child who attends that school. Those children now know that strangers can come into their school, the place where they learn and socialize and grow, and destroy their things. Those boys destroyed computers, furniture, and art work that children took pride in; they defiled walls and desks with swastikas and inappropriate images. The children at that school had to wonder: Who would do that, and will they come back?

The new synagogue, still incomplete, is a source of pride to Jewish residents of my town. We have worked hard to build it—to raise the funds, and see the first new synagogue in more than 100 years, to accommodate our growing congregation, and have a place for our Jewish kids to learn about their faith, and heritage. Swastikas—all over the site. What were these boys thinking? Did they intend to instill fear and a sense of hatred toward Jews, in both locations… or did they just think this was a kind of graffiti that they’d seen other places? And most importantly, Where did they learn this?

As the clever group of women that I was with expressed their shock that my kids have experienced such blatant anti-semitism throughout their childhoods in this town we love so much, another Jewish parent assured them that her children had experienced the same things. It is not that often that I have that kind of back up. There are not a lot of Jewish parents where we live, so I’m not usually having this conversation with another parent who can say “us too.”  More than once, I’ve sensed that someone thinks that somehow my kids exaggerated, or that maybe they did something that provoked that kind of rhetoric. As someone who did not grow up Jewish, I continue to be shocked at how easily anti-semitism slips from lips, how it is excused and tolerated, even by very intelligent, compassionate people, who would not tolerate the N word, or blatant racial prejudice.

Sometimes I wonder whether it is that there is still a subtle and intrinsic belief, on the part of some people, that Jews don’t really count as a persecuted group— as people who are singled out for prejudice. The Holocaust, while taught in schools and viewed as a horrific event (by most intelligent people), is also seen as an isolated event, carried out by a maniacal man… who somehow bullied an entire nation into committing atrocities on the most horrific of scales. It is often overlooked that other nations did not do much to stop it, or to call it out, until things were very clearly beyond question. At the time, and through much of history, Jews were already viewed as many of the names and labels that Hitler used to bring his country on board. Those names and stereotypes were openly used in the US and many other places around the world.  The subject of Israel today, a predominantly Jewish nation, often includes a subtext that suggests that the Israelis are difficult or unreasonable.  Ok, I am fully aware that there are enormous complexities to that discussion… Been there, seen that, and only in the smallest of ways… but enough to make me think differently, and look at that picture through a little wider lens. But still, when discussing the issues in the Middle East, I often find myself uneasy, when I sense that some of the counter arguments stem from a passive anti-semitism, wrapped in political rhetoric.

I suppose I’ve digressed here; it’s a slippery slope. Parenting is tough. It is the hardest and best job that I’ve done in life, no doubt. It’s filled with the highest of highs and some of the lowest of lows. I’ve learned that it is a very short while that our babes are truly living entirely in our orbit. From the time we drop them at kindergarten, until the time they are truly “on their own” (as if we ever truly accept that “truly”), they begin to see the world through so many other eyes. They have teachers, religious leaders, media and friends, helping them determine what they think and how they will behave out in this big world. Each day they are gone from us for at least 6 long hours, where they are being impacted and informed on all kinds of things that may or may not gel with what we’ve taught them at home. They may or may not be exposed to all kinds of small injustices and  unkind words, that are slipped in out of our sight. Our kids do not always bring those things home for discussion, but they filter them and figure out on their own what to do with the material.

image: joeyheadset.com

image: joeyheadset.com

So, whenever I hear people saying” that we should look at his/her home,” or “we ought to hold his/her parents accountable,” in response to something a young person has done, I stop and remember the instances when I have seen all kinds of kids say and do things that I find entirely reprehensible, and their parents were equally hurt and mystified. I see why it is easy to look at it that way; I once assumed similar reasoning. We all want to compartmentalize bad things, and find the ways that it can’t happen to us. The boys in the Steubenville rape case must come from horrible homes, right? The whole town somehow breeds that, or so it has been widely suggested. Kids who say racist things must have heard those things at home, yes? If all of that is true, we can safely assess that our own kids will never be the guilty party, because we are good parents, who don’t teach those things… right? However, again, I have learned that many apples do fall far from their trees, and the proof is not always in the pudding. Sometimes the pudding tastes nothing like the  original recipe, and we are left to ask… then why?

Share your thoughts in the comment section. Weigh in. Then hit Like. Just do it. Thanks. Feel free to visit the Tales From the Motherland Facebook page, and hit like.

About Dawn Quyle Landau

Mother, Writer, treasure hunter, aging red head, and sushi lover. This is my view on life, "Straight up, with a twist––" because life is too short to be subtle! Featured blogger for Huffington Post, and followed on Twitter by LeBron James– for reasons beyond my comprehension.
This entry was posted in Aging, Awareness, Blog, bullying, Daily Observations, Education, Honest observations on many things, Israel, Jewish, Judaism, Life, Mothers, Musings, News, Tales From the Motherland, Teens and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

25 Responses to The Proof Is Not Always In the Pudding….

  1. Dan Hennessy says:

    Thanks for a heartfelt discussion involving several serious issues .

    Like

  2. Well done, Dawn. It’s not so black and white, is it? I agree. There’s a continuum with evil, malicious acts at one end, and intelligence, tolerance, love and humanity on the other. These ignorant acts and the motivations for them can fall anywhere along the continuum (obviously closer to the one end). Kids can be plain old stupid and then again, they can be malicious. It’s hard to know what the drive is/was.
    Regardless, I think we should have, not just anti-bullying/ anti-hate programs in the schools, but we should have actual classes taught as part of the curriculum – a historical look at hate; globally, nationally and locally. You could explore moral and ethical behavior, etc. It’s sad but I think that our children, at this point in time, need to be exposed to the negative impact and consequences of persecution, hate, racism, bigotry, prejudice, etc. The objective would be to create awareness of these issues/feelings both internally and in the world around them. It’s sad but I don’t think we can rely on what is being taught at home – if we can teach and encourage love, compassion and tolerance from an academic perspective we might be doing something preventative. Just an idea…
    Great post, per usual. 🙂

    Like

    • Thanks Lisa! Very thoughtful and well stated comment. I agree that it would be so helpful and potentially meaningful, for these dialogues to be in school… and start much earlier than they do. The Holocaust is taught in most schools, as is the Civil Rights period, but not in a manner (generally) that truly looks at emotional content and impact. Thanks for weighing in!

      Like

  3. I have lived in a several cities and towns in the western states, and I am all too aware that racism and hate, if not clearly visible, float close below the surface. If we pretend the haters, bigots and racists do not exist, if we tolerate them, it only serves to validate them. Like the teenage vandals you mentioned, they need to be confronted.
    I praise you for putting your message out here for all to see. – Mike

    Like

  4. Julia Connors says:

    After I read this post, I was musing on how amazing you are at being exactly who your kids needed as their mother, how incredibly articulate and soulful a writer you are and that if the universe had not given me my own mother, and had I a choice in the matter, I would have chosen you in a heartbeat! You rock my dear one, you rock!

    Like

  5. Very sad to read this. There was a racist incident at Oberlin College recently and they cancelled classes to address it. I think kids get stuff from everywhere- and you’re right we can’t assume they learned this at home. But it does make you wonder, just like kids whose parents have guns around. I hope the community finds ways to heal and continue educating against ignorance and prejudice.

    Like

    • I think it’s the world that needs healing… I venture to say that there is far too much of it right here in the states, but I do not believe for a moment that it’s only in our community. This story was a blip in the news… focusing predominantly on the damage to computers and iPads… not on the implications or potential meanings of the things these boys wrote/carved. Again, it is not seen as all that serious… relative to the destruction of property. Sad.

      Like

  6. Powerful post. It’s hard to believe that people still take up old time offences to this measure. Frankly, having never met a Jewish person, and having almost thought they were entirely extinct thanks to Hitler I’d be rather intrigued.

    You are very right to say that so many things happen to the kids going to school, the parents are hardly accountable for much of their actions and sometimes even morals. Sad, but true.

    Like

  7. Agree– no act of prejudice, bigotry, racism should be considered an “old time” offence that can be taken at all lightly.

    Like

  8. WordsFallFromMyEyes says:

    This is an enormously worthy post, and obviously close to your home. My Mother (r.i.p.) was a Polish refugee. The very sign of the nazi symbol…

    Yes, complex. And tragic.

    Like

  9. mamaheidi60 says:

    Wow! Once again you shine light where it is often too dark for others to even look. I would venture to say that a small part of the problem is that when history is taught, it is history and there may not be enough emphasis on relating history to contemporary social/political events. But that is certainly not an explanation. Right after 9/11, I talked with a Muslim mother here in town who told me that her children were subjected to much taunting in school, but that she knew they kept it from her to protect her from her own worries for how they were getting along, during the day, away from her. We hugged and I shed tears with her that this was happening in our beloved town. From all of this, I take away that parents do their best, but they can’t do it alone! Our greater society/community has a huge part in this!!! I don’t know the answer, but I do believe we need more emphasis on what kind of people our children are being raised to be, rather that what achievements they attain. Good food for thought here. I’m just realizing that I don’t see the “hands against hate” symbol around any more. More community action? Obviously to be continued! Good for you for sticking your neck out here!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Like

    • Thanks Mama… how strange that I didn’t see this as sticking my neck out there at all, but perhaps I have? Hmm. Several similar comments, but my perspective felt different. I really do try to write without my filters on. If I got thinking too much about who was reading, what they might think of me, etc, I might not be as honest. How’s that for reality? Not sure what the answers are here… but the problem surely exists. Thanks, as always, for your honest and compassionate responses. hugs.

      Like

      • mamaheidi60 says:

        I don’t know that “stick your neck out” is the best description, but, seriously, what coverage has there been about this? I had know idea it was swastikas. Although any type of hateful desecration is desecration, where is the community conversation? You are just writing about your own experience and observation, but it makes me wonder why there isn’t more widespread conversation…

        Like

        • I could not agree more Heidi! I don’t understand why this was not reported more directly. It feels like critical details were left out of the news, while man of us (parents at the school, synagogue members) know the details. It was implied or reported in a a round about manner in the Herald. Totally agree that there should be a more open community dialogue about issues like this, but it’s been my experience (over the years and 3 kids in school) that the topic goes undiscussed, for the most part. Thanks for weighing in!

          Like

  10. Lyssapants says:

    It’s complicated, and I appreciate that you’re unwilling to make assumptions before getting more information.

    Like

    • I think I live in the gray zone too much sometimes, but it I ams what I yams. I have seen enough surprising things, to believe that things truly are not what we think they are, all of the time. Sometimes they are, but there is a lot of gray to live in. 😉

      Like

  11. When I worked in the Baltimore schools many years ago I remember a boy in 5th grade putting on a fake Hitler style mustache and prancing Nazi style, with his arm raised in a “Heil Hitler” salute. He thought he was being funny, and I was so outraged that I’m afraid my response was not as educational as it should have been…

    Like

  12. I’ve wondered if some of it isn’t just kids needing to try things out to see what the response is or some burst from their emotions they haven’t learned to curb, nor understand why they should. Response of those around them is crucial in the learning process and yes, parents can be quite oblivious to their children. Also, I don’t think babies are “blank slates.” From birth we seem to exhibit a variety of personality quirks. So there’s answer. I haven’t read the above ones, but you’ve probably had other similar ones.

    Like

    • Thank you so much for stopping by this blog, and taking the time to share your thoughts! I hope you’ll check out others, and join in. I agree with much of what you say here… it’s all a big mix of many things, going into the pot. It is hard to know why things that seem reprehensible to those of us who are older, are so tantalizing to some young people… So many influences and so many ways to look at this. Again, thanks for sharing!

      Like

  13. Pingback: Grab a Tissue Because it’s Time for The First Inaugural MRTB Roast. | MY RIGHT TO BITCH

PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT; I'M LISTENING.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s